Notes to the consolidated financial statements of the Helsana Group

1. Income statement – Supplementary information on the business areas (divisions)

1. Income statement – 
Supplementary information on the business areas (divisions)
  Insurance under KVG 1 Insurance under VVG 2   Insurance under UVG 3   Other 4   Elimination   Total
2016 2015 2016 2015 2016 2015 2016 2015 2016 2015 2016 2015
                         
Net premiums earned 4,521,402 4,326,652 1,701,603 1,549,818 147,393 145,445 0 0 –157 –40,160 6,370,241 5,981,755
                         
Net cost of claims and benefits –4,692,037 –4,604,727 –1,280,701 –1,143,561 –128,880 –128,551 0 0 157 1,074 –6,101,461 –5,875,765
                         
Allocated interest 0 0 0 0 10,020 9,804 0 0 0 0 10,020 9,804
Risk adjustment between insurers 434,630 375,042 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 434,630 375,042
Policyholder participation –8,515 –6,689 –23,239 –18,331 –2,505 –1,071 0 0 0 0 –34,258 –26,091
Net operating expenses –273,635 –251,001 –326,857 –370,599 –23,901 –21,577 0 –806 0 42,028 –624,393 –601,955
Underwriting result –18,155 –160,723 70,806 17,327 2,127 4,050 0 –806 0 2,942 54,778 –137,210
                         
Investment income 221,732 249,453 283,092 308,316 95,104 110,297 85,175 149,034 –30,000 –110,906 655,103 706,193
Investment expenses –153,435 –191,754 –200,213 –269,117 –52,894 –75,592 –41,111 –42,056 0 11,074 –447,653 –567,444
Change in provision for investment risk –10,000 20,000 –97,000 15,000 5,000 0 –50,000 –20,000 0 0 –152,000 15,000
Earnings from investments 58,297 77,699 –14,121 54,199 47,210 34,705 –5,936 86,978 –30,000 –99,832 55,450 153,749
                         
Allocated interest expenses   0   0 –10,020 –9,804 0 0 0 0 –10,020 –9,804
Other operating income 7,211 5,977 6,401 4,146 750 886 1,068 811 –1,082 –1,226 14,348 10,594
Other operating expenses –2,657 –2,848 –2,100 –2,676 –920 –573 –1,241 –656 1,082 1,057 –5,837 –5,696
Operating earnings 44,696 –79,895 60,986 72,996 39,148 29,264 –6,110 86,327 –30,000 –97,059 108,720 11,633
                         
Non-operating earnings –190 10,827 790 4,407 –41 –1 2,098 10,701 0 –9,941 2,657 15,993
Exceptional earnings –24 –7,057 –5 0 0 0 0 10 0 7,000 –28 –47
                         
Consolidated earnings before taxes 44,482 –76,125 61,771 77,403 39,107 29,263 –4,012 97,038 –30,000 –100,000 111,349 27,579
                         
Deferred income taxes 0 0 59,008 39,555 –1,711 29,756 116 171 0 0 57,412 69,482
Income taxes 0 0 –64,797 –57,971 –4,512 –20,948 –718 –1,227 0 0 –70,027 –80,146
Non-controlling interest 0 0 0 0 0 0 –765 –979 0 0 –765 –979
                         
Consolidated earnings 44,482 –76,125 55,982 58,987 32,884 38,071 –5,379 95,003 –30,000 –100,000 97,969 15,936

1 Insurance under KVG This segment comprises the companies that offer mandatory health care insurance and voluntary daily benefits insurance under the KVG.

2 Insurance under VVG This segment comprises the companies that offer insurance products under the VVG.

3 Insurance under UVG This segment comprises the companies that offer insurance products under the UVG.

4 Other This segment comprises all other companies.

2. Consolidation and accounting principles

General

For the first time, the consolidated financial statements 2015 are being presented in accordance with the Swiss GAAP accounting and reporting recommendations (Swiss GAAP FER) and they provide a true and fair view of the Group's assets, finances and earnings. Swiss GAAP FER represents a complete body of rules. All recommenda- tions must be applied.

Swiss GAAP FER 41 entered into force for the individual financial statements of KVG health insurers on 1 January 2012. The Helsana Group applied Swiss GAAP FER 30 (Consolidation) in conjunction with Swiss GAAP FER 41 from financial year 2015. The application of Swiss GAAP FER is voluntary.

Consolidated companies

The consolidated financial statements include all companies that are directly or indirectly controlled by Helsana. Control means the decisive influence on the operational and financial activities in order to derive the corresponding benefit therefrom. This is usually the case if Helsana directly or indirectly holds more than 50 per cent of the voting rights in a company. Companies acquired duringthe financial year are included from the date on which control over the business activities was transferred to Helsana, and all companies disposed of during the year are excluded from the Group statements from the date of sale.

Change in consolidated companies

Purchasing Cooperative HSK Ltd was founded in Dübendorf on 22 December 2015 and included in the scope of consolidation. The first annual financial statement for Purchasing Cooperative HSK Ltd will be prepared as at 31 December 2016 (long financial year) and included in the capital consolidation as at 31 December 2016.

Rounding differences

All amounts in the annual financial statements are rounded to thousand Swiss francs. This means that the sum of several rounded amounts added together can differ from the rounded total that is reported.

2.1 Consolidation method

Full consolidation

Companies are included in the Group statements based on the full consolidation method. Capital consolidation is carried out using the Anglo-Saxon method (purchase method). Assets and borrowed capital of companies acquired are revalued at the time of control changes in accordance with the Helsana Group's principles; unrealised gains and losses are carried under the relevant balance sheet items and the remaining difference between the purchase price and goodwill calculated according to the accounting policies of the Group is fully amortised over five years or in the year of consolidation. Any third-party participations in fully consolidated companies are shown separately as non-controlling interests in equity and income.

Equity method 

Companies in which Helsana holds between a 20 and 50 per cent stake are stated in the balance sheet at the value corresponding to the pro rata equity capital in line with the equity method.

Consolidation reporting date

The reporting date for all companies included is 31 December.

Events after the reporting date

On 1 January 2017, Helsana Insurance Company Ltd absorbed Avanex Insurance Ltd and Progrès Insurance Ltd absorbed Sansan Insurance Ltd by way of a merger in accordance with Art. 3 para. I A of the Swiss Merger Act (FusG). The assets and liabilities of these companies were assumed through universal succession.

Moreover, there were no significant events after the reporting date until the date of signature by the responsible body (7 February 2017).

Intragroup transactions

All intragroup transactions, relationships and earnings are eliminated as part of the consolidation process.

2.2 Valuation principles

Valuation is carried out in line with standardised criteria. In general, the principle of the individual valuation of assets and liabilities applies.

Foreign currencies

Foreign currency positions are converted at current exchange rates at year-end.

The following exchange rates were used:

  31.12.2016 31.12.2015
Unit / currency Price Price
     
1 EUR 1.07198 1.08737
1 GBP 1.25589 1.47536
1 USD 1.01636 1.00100
100 JPY 0.87140 0.83210
1 CAD 0.75786 0.72062
1 AUD 0.73594 0.72831

Investments

Real estate

Real estate includes both investment properties and owner-occupied properties, and is recognised in the balance sheet at current market value. Market values are estimated at least once every three years by an independent consulting firm. The values are determined using the discounted cash flow method or another recognised method during the intervening years.

Bonds

Fixed-income securities are recognised in the balance sheet using the amortised cost method if the debtor is able to pay the interest and amortisation payments. Periodic changes in the carrying amount are recognised in the income statement. If there are justified doubts about the debtor's ability to pay interest and amortisation payments, fixed-income securities are recognised in the balance sheet at their current value.

Equities

Equities include equity securities such as stocks and similar securities.

Such assets are marketable and are valued at market price. Any impairments are booked accordingly.

Real estate funds

Real estate funds are maintained as a separate item. They are measured at current value.

Currency futures

Derivatives include foreign exchange and option contracts, certificates on equity indices and futures. Forward exchange transactions are used to hedge exchange rate and market price fluctuations and are measured at market value.

Investments in other companies

These include investments in companies that are held for strategic purposes. These investments are measured using the last known pro rata equity (equity method) or are valued at cost.

Loans and mortgages

Loans and mortgages are stated in the balance sheet at nominal value less any necessary write-downs.

Assets from employer reserves

Assets from employer reserves are, provided they are not subject to a waiver of usage, recognised in the balance sheet at their nominal value and deducted from staff costs accordingly if they are used. The value is reviewed annually and, if necessary, the item is written down.

Collateral for own liabilities as well as assets under reservation of ownership

All investments and cash holdings except for the KVG, VVG and UVG segments are reported as tied assets.

Intangible assets

With intangible assets, a distinction is drawn between purchased software and projects. The latter are amortised on a straight-line basis over the course of their useful life. With purchased software, amounts below CHF 5,000 are expensed.

Projects are generally amortised over a period of five years from launch, up to a maximum of ten years in justified cases. They must provide a benefit over several years. At maximum, they are measured at cost of acquisition or production. These costs must be measurable and allocable to the project. Projects may only be capitalised if they are strategic in nature and involve an investment in excess of CHF 3 million.

Fixed assets

Fixed assets are depreciated on a straight-line basis over the course of their useful life. For fixtures and fittings, acquisitions and collective acquisitions for amounts of more than CHF 5,000 are capitalised. Amounts below this limit are expensed.

Useful life for each asset category:

  • Five years for fixtures and fittings
  • Three years for IT hardware
  • Three years for vehicles

The value is reviewed annually and the item is written down accordingly.

Prepaid expenses and accrued income

This item includes expenses during the reporting year that are deducted as an expense in the following financial year, and income that only leads to revenue in the following financial year.

Receivables

Receivables due from third parties, such as policyholders, insurance organisations, agents and brokers, cantons and other parties, are measured at nominal value. The security is determined on the basis of the maturity structure and recognisable credit risks. In addition to individual write-downs for specific known receivable risks, impairments are formed using statistical information about the risk of default. The calculation of the necessary value adjustments also includes the type of receivable (private customer, corporate customer, co-payment) in addition to the maturity structure. The assumptions are based on historical figures from previous years. Assuming the losses on accounts remain constant as in previous years, an allowance for doubt- ful receivables is made for the unpaid receivables up to 180 days with a rate of 0.25 %. For older receivables, the effects of Art. 64a KVG (depending on the canton) are included in the calculation of the allowance for doubt- ful receivables of the KVG companies. The totals of the receivables are included in the ratio of the debt collection proceedings initiated to the resulting certificates of debt.

The receivables due from affiliates are measured at nominal value, taking account of operationally necessary impairments.

Cash and cash equivalents

Cash and cash equivalents include cash on hand as well as postal and bank account balances. Cash and cash equivalents are measured at nominal value. Any impairments are booked accordingly.

Net technical provisions

The item for net technical provisions includes provisions for claims and benefits, actuarial reserves, provisions for profit sharing, technical equalisation reserves and provisions for guarantees as well as other technical provisions.

Provisions for claims and benefits are calculated according to actuarial methods recognised by the supervisory authorities (e.g. chain ladder). In doing so, the following parameters are taken into account for the year of occurrence and the year of processing:

  • First year of treatment versus payment year for care benefits
  • First year of event versus payment year for daily benefits

The reserves for annuities are calculated according to the accounting principles pursuant to Art.108 UVV. The calculation is based on the annuity without cost of living bonuses. For ceded co-insurance, we assume our portion of the individual actuarial reserve as reported by the company that carries it.

For group sickness benefits, provisions for profit sharing are formed for contracts that include agreements on profit sharing. They are calculated as the expected value of the profit share paid out after the reporting date for contracts for profit sharing that are in effect through the reporting date. The estimate of provisions for profit sharing takes account of the active portfolio and the empirical claims experience as at the reporting date.

The equalisation reserves and provisions for guarantees protect the capital base against the effects of unusual fluctuations in the technical result. They are endowed up to a maximum limit of 15 per cent of the insurance benefits in line with the technical result. The lower limit is zero.

The other technical provisions include additional actuarial provisions that are measured according to the applicable and approved business plan.

Non-technical provisions

If an outflow of funds is probable, a corresponding provision is raised for legal and actual obligations on an event in the past. The amount is determined by analysing the relevant past result and the economic risk. If time has a significant impact, the provision requirement must be discounted. The provisions are revalued annually.

Provision for investment risk

The provision for investment risk maps the long-term volatilities of the capital market. The provision is based on the total portfolio and is reviewed annually. The target provision for investment risk is calculated on the basis of

  • ten per cent of Swiss bonds
  • three per cent of properties and buildings as well as
  • 20 per cent of other investments.

If the investments during the reporting period experience above-average losses in value, the provision for investment risk can also be liquidated in the income statement in full or in part. If the value of the investments increase by more than the average during the reporting period, the provision for investment risk can also be increased in full or in part to the target value in the income statement.

Accrued expenses and deferred income

This item includes deferred income during the reporting year that is credited as income in the following financial year, and expenses for the reporting year that are only paid the following financial year.

Liabilities

This item mainly includes obligations to policyholders or service providers as well as premiums billed in advance. Loans due are also recognised in this item. The liabilities are recognised in the balance sheet at their nominal amount.

3. 2016 consolidated companies

3. 2016 consolidated companies
Name Sector Consolidation Shareholding in % Capital in CHF m
         
Helsana Ltd, Dübendorf Holding Fully consolidated 100 70.0
– Helsana Insurance Company Ltd, Dübendorf Health insurance Fully consolidated 100 70.0
– Helsana Supplementary Insurances Ltd, Dübendorf Health insurance Fully consolidated 100 35.0
– LCC Consulting AG, Zurich Software engineering Fully consolidated 100 0.1
– Helsana Legal Protection Ltd, Aarau Legal expenses insurance Equity method 50 3.0
– Progrès Insurance Ltd, Dübendorf Health insurance Fully consolidated 100 0.3
– Sansan Insurance Ltd, Dübendorf Health insurance Fully consolidated 100 0.1
– Avanex Insurance Ltd, Dübendorf Health insurance Fully consolidated 100 0.1
         
– Helsana Accidents Ltd, Dübendorf Accident insurance Fully consolidated 100 14.0
– Solida Insurance Ltd, Zurich Accident insurance Equity method 50 10.0
         
– Helsana Investment Ltd, Dübendorf Holding Fully consolidated 100 0.1
– indivo Insurance Ltd, Dübendorf Health insurance Fully consolidated 100 0.1
– SSS Schaden Service Switzerland Ltd, Zurich Recourse settlement Fully consolidated 50.9 0.1
– Procare Vorsorge AG, Dübendorf Services Fully consolidated 100 0.1
– Purchasing Cooperative HSK Ltd., Dübendorf Services Fully consolidated 60 0.1
– Aviga AG, Zurich Case management Equity method 50 1.0
– Topwell-Apotheken AG, Winterthur Healthcare sector Equity method 24.1 0.3

4. Notes to the consolidated income statement

4. Notes to the consolidated income statement
Figures in CHF thousand 2,016 2015
     
Premium income 6,371,065 5,982,627
Reinsurers' share –824 –872
Total net premiums earned 6,370,241 5,981,755
     
Cost of claims and benefits –6,675,433 –6,449,511
Co-payments 646,188 638,539
Reinsurers' share 2,195 2,349
Change in technical provisions –16,444 –12,726
Loss mitigation costs –57,967 –54,416
Total net cost of claims and benefits –6,101,461 –5,875,765
     
Personnel expenses –365,381 –365,217
Administrative offices and operating equipment –27,413 –26,781
IT costs –94,048 –66,545
Marketing, advertising and commission –92,495 –115,058
Other administrative expenses –31,322 –17,654
Write-downs –13,734 –10,700
Total operating expenses, net –624,393 –601,955
     
Liquid funds (interest) 8,521 6,751
Receivables (interest risk adjustment, default interest, etc.) 4,143 3,831
Other income 1,684 12
Total other operating income 14,348 10,594
     
Liquid funds (interest) –4,777 –5,189
Liabilities (interest risk adjustment, etc.) –95 –43
Other expenses –965 –464
Total other operating expenses –5,837 –5,696
     
Non-operating income, third party 17,103 23,966
Non-operating expenses, third party –14,446 –7,973
Total non-operating income 2,657 15,993
     
Extraordinary income 0 10
Extraordinary expenses –28 –57
Total extraordinary income –28 –47

5. Notes to the consolidated income statement – investments

5. Notes to the consolidated income statement – 
investments
Figures in CHF thousand Ordinary earnings Realised gains Unrealised gains Total 2015
         
Investment income        
Real estate 18,737 0 0 18,737
Bonds 88,804 225,789 19,835 334,428
Equities 26,369 81,783 61,041 169,193
Alternative investments 0 0 3,052 3,052
Real estate funds 0 46,226 29,058 75,284
Currency futures 0 91,753 0 91,753
Investments in other companies 191 1,562 9,997 11,750
Employer contribution reserve 0 209 0 209
Other investment income 1 1,787 0 0 1,787
Total investment income 135,888 447,322 122,983 706,193
         
         
Figures in CHF thousand Administrative costs Realised losses Non-realised losses Total 2015
         
Investment expenses        
Real estate 0 0 –1,827 –1,827
Bonds 0 –202,591 –58,795 –261,386
Equities 0 –59,033 –83,827 –142,860
Alternative investments 0 –8,379 –30,423 –38,802
Real estate funds 0 –3,674 –29,177 –32,851
Currency futures 0 –63,376 –10,890 –74,266
Investments in other companies 0 0 –2,325 –2,325
Employer contribution reserve 0 –1,896 0 –1,896
Asset management costs –11,231 0 0 –11,231
Total investment expenses –11,231 –338,949 –217,264 –567,444
         
Change in provision for investment risk 0 0 15,000 15,000
Total investment income 2015 124,657 108,373 –79,281 153,749
Figures in CHF thousand Ordinary earnings Realised gains Unrealised gains Total 2016
         
Investment income        
Real estate 18,925 126 8,553 27,604
Bonds 82,298 172,272 3,896 258,466
Equities 23,857 64,023 100,097 187,977
Alternative investments 0 0 20,289 20,289
Real estate funds 0 79,941 23,951 103,892
Currency futures 0 30,491 15,243 45,734
Investments in other companies 234 1,566 9,027 10,827
Employer contribution reserve 0 0 167 167
Other investment income 1 147 0 0 147
Total investment income 125,461 348,419 181,223 655,103
         
         
Figures in CHF thousand Administrative costs Realised losses Non-realised losses Total 2016
         
Investment expenses        
Real estate 0 –6 –5,410 –5,416
Bonds 0 –144,938 –8,299 –153,237
Equities 0 –73,981 –73,365 –147,346
Alternative investments 0 –35 –3,621 –3,656
Real estate funds 0 –14,830 –55,064 –69,894
Currency futures 0 –51,553 –1,910 –53,463
Investments in other companies 0 0 –26 –26
Employer contribution reserve 0 0 –1,378 –1,378
Asset management costs –13,237 0 0 –13,237
Total investment expenses –13,237 –285,343 –149,073 –447,653
         
Change in provision for investment risk     –152,000 –152,000
Total investment income 2016 112,224 63,076 –119,850 55,450

1 Other investment income comprises retrocession repayments by the custodian financial institution.

6. Notes to the consolidated balance sheet – investments

6. Notes to the consolidated balance sheet – investments

6. Notes to the consolidated balance sheet – 
investments
Figures in CHF thousand As at 1.1.2015 Additions /  disposals Change in valuation adjustment As at 31.12.2015
         
Real estate 318,265 865 –1,827 317,303
Bonds 1 3,671,904 35,362 –38,959 3,668,307
Equities 1,099,502 53,187 –22,785 1,129,904
Alternative investments 109,366 51,535 –27,371 133,530
Real estate funds 530,448 –47,460 –120 482,868
Currency futures –14,005 14,005 –10,891 –10,891
Investments in other companies 67,072 488 7,672 75,232
Loans and mortgages 10 –3 0 7
Employer contribution reserve 8,374 –1,687 0 6,687
Investments 5,790,936 106,292 –94,281 5,802,947
         
Figures in CHF thousand As at 31.12.2015 Additions /  disposals Change in valuation adjustment As at 31.12.2016
         
Real estate 317,303 6,404 3,143 326,850
Bonds 1 3,668,307 46,655 –4,404 3,710,558
Equities 1,129,904 12,945 26,732 1,169,581
Alternative investments 133,530 66,943 16,668 217,139
Real estate funds 482,868 67,683 –31,113 519,437
Currency futures –10,891 0 13,333 2,442
Investments in other companies 75,232 –550 9,001 83,683
Loans and mortgages 7 6 0 13
Employer contribution reserve 6,687 0 –1,211 5,476
Investments 5,802,947 200,085 32,149 6,035,180

1 The market value of the bonds (excluding accrued interest) is CHF 3,843,759,000 (CHF 3,857,716,000 as at 31 December 2015).

7. Currency futures

7. Currency futures
      Market value as at 31.12.2016 Market value as at 31.12.2015
Figures in CHF thousand   Currency Positive Negative Positive Negative
             
Futures Hedges CHF 3,378 0 2,355 –1,181
Futures Hedges USD 0 –511 1 –3,183
Futures Hedges EUR 24 0 0 –42
Futures Hedges JPY 0 0 9,328 0
Total in bonds 1     3,402 –511 11,684 –4,406
             
Futures Hedges USD 0 –917 0 –9,389
Futures Hedges EUR 1,264 0 0 –2,494
Futures Hedges GBP 2,095 0 992 0
Total currency futures     3,359 –917 992 –11,883

1 The bond hedges are included in the bond asset class.

8. Statement of asset additions and disposals Fixed and intangible assets

8. Statement of asset additions and disposals
Fixed and intangible assets
Figures in CHF thousand Office fixtures, fittings and equipment IT hardware Vehicles Total property, plant and equipment Projects Software Total intangible assets
               
Net carrying amount as at 1.1.2015 6,199 7,245 93 13,537 6,136 6,620 12,757
               
Historical cost              
Carrying amount as at 1.1.2015 143,234 50,516 567 194,317 9,204 8,276 17,480
Asset additions 1,990 7,283 199 9,472 42,988 10,703 53,691
Asset disposals 0 –6,283 –98 –6,381 0 0 0
Carrying amount as at 31.12.2015 145,224 51,516 668 197,408 52,192 18,979 71,171
               
Accumulated valuation adjustments              
Value adjustments as at 1.1.2015 –137,035 –43,272 –473 –180,780 –3,068 –1,655 –4,723
Depreciation and amortisation –2,004 –6,558 –121 –8,683 –17,397 –3,796 –21,193
Asset disposals 0 5,877 58 5,935 0 0 0
Value adjustments as at 31.12.2015 –139,039 –43,953 –536 –183,528 –20,465 –5,451 –25,916
               
Net carrying amount 31.12.2015 6,185 7,563 132 13,880 31,727 13,528 45,255
Figures in CHF thousand Office fixtures, fittings and equipment IT hardware Vehicles Total property, plant and equipment Projects Software Total intangible assets
               
Net carrying amount as at 31.12.2015 6,185 7,563 132 13,880 31,727 13,528 45,255
               
Historical cost              
Carrying amount as at 31.12.2015 145,224 51,516 668 197,408 52,192 18,979 71,171
Asset additions 1,998 2,644 20 4,662 56,735 7,763 64,498
Asset disposals 0 –2,507 –2 –2,509 0 0 0
Carrying amount as at 31.12.2016 147,222 51,653 686 199,561 108,927 26,742 135,669
               
Accumulated valuation adjustments              
Value adjustments as at 31.12.2015 –139,039 –43,953 –536 –183,528 –20,465 –5,451 –25,916
Depreciation and amortisation –2,383 –6,020 –85 –8,488 –36,309 –5,348 –41,657
Asset disposals 0 2,506 2 2,508 0 0 0
Value adjustments as at 31.12.2016 –141,422 –47,467 –619 –189,508 –56,774 –10,799 –67,573
               
Net carrying amount as at 31.12.2016 5,800 4,186 67 10,053 52,153 15,943 68,096

9. Deferred charges and credits

9. Deferred charges and credits
Figures in CHF thousand 31.12.2016 31.12.2015
     
Accrued interest on investments 36,270 41,328
Risk compensation 293,551 280,370
Other accrued income and prepaid expenses 84,697 110,972
Total deferred charges 414,518 432,670
     
Risk compensation 68,287 89,458
Other deferred income and accrued expenses 27,806 33,759
Total deferred credits 96,093 123,217

10. Receivables and liabilities

10. Receivables and liabilities
Figures in CHF thousand 31.12.2016 31.12.2015
     
Policyholders 284,573 205,550
Insurance organisations 6,614 11,234
Related parties 1,338 4,350
Government offices 4,982 35,402
Other receivables 45,845 14,633
Total receivables 343,352 271,169
     
Policyholders 357,625 402,462
Insurance organisations 1,067 2,226
Service providers 95,309 212,098
Agents and brokers 1,790 1,885
Related parties 2,220 3,679
Government offices 709 3,045
Other liabilities 123,002 17,549
Total liabilities 581,722 642,944

11. Technical provisions

11. Technical provisions
Figures in CHF thousand Provision for claims and benefits 1 Actuarial reserve 2 Provision for policyholder participation Claims equalisation reserve Other technical provisions 3 Total
             
As at 1.1.2015 1,536,603 408,852 72,320 800,653 568,922 3,387,350
Creation 1,215,485 13,144 12,401 0 12,734 1,253,764
Release –1,155,419 –1,855 –26,091 –55,000 –2,673 –1,241,038
As at 31.12.2015 1,596,669 420,141 58,630 745,653 578,983 3,400,076
Figures in CHF thousand Provision for claims and benefits 1 Actuarial reserve 2 Provision for policyholder participation Claims equalisation reserve Other technical provisions 3 Total
             
As at 31.12.2015 1,596,669 420,141 58,630 745,653 578,983 3,400,076
Creation 1,256,732 0 794,638 41,061 412,250 2,504,681
Release –1,242,022 0 –789,856 –54,900 –401,459 –2,488,238
Restatement       2,055 –2,055 0
As at 31.12.2016 1,611,379 420,141 63,412 733,869 587,719 3,416,519

1 The amount of reinsurance in the provisions for claims and benefits was CHF 0 as at 31 December 2015 (CHF –1,492,000 as at 31.12.2015).

2 The actuarial reserves were discounted with a technical interest rate of 2.75 per cent for the accident years up to 2013 and 2.0 per cent for 2014, 2015 and 2016 (Average term: 14.9 years).

3 The other technical provisions comprise provisions for other compulsory health insurance products (OKP) (models such as HAV / HMO). Ageing reserves were discounted with a technical interest rate of 1.0 per cent (Average term: 39.2 years).

12. Non-technical provisions

12. Non-technical provisions
Figures in CHF thousand Restructuring Personnel /  brokers Taxes IT investments Process risks Other 2 Total
               
As at 1.1.2015 12,225 38,970 19,958 0 213 76,766 148,132
Creation 3,000 27,840 58,382 380 0 9,551 99,153
Use –9,958 –43,480 –24,560 –22 –213 –27,365 –105,598
As at 31.12.2015 5,267 23,330 53,780 358 0 58,952 141,687
Figures in CHF thousand Restructuring Personnel /  brokers Taxes IT investments Process risks Other 2 Total
               
As at 31.12.2015 5,267 23,330 53,780 358 0 58,952 141,687
Creation 628 27,345 104,875 368 0 –1,281 131,935
Use –4,240 –27,298 –90,786 –726 0 –32,296 –155,346
As at 31.12.2016 1,655 23,377 67,869 0 0 25,375 118,277

1 The restructuring provisions include the costs of the organisational changes that were made as part of the cost reduction programme. The provisions for holiday and overtime claims as well as staff bonuses and broker fees are included under “Personnel /  brokers”.

2 The other non-technical provisions include past provisions for subsequent premium corrections. In 2014, the Swiss Parliament decided to correct the imbalances in basic health insurance premiums accumulated from 1996 to 2013 in accordance with Art. 106 of the Federal Health Insurance Act (KVG). The financial correction process will take place between 2015 and 2017.

13. Provision for investment risk

13. Provision for investment risk
Figures in CHF thousand Provision for investment risk Total
     
As at 1.1.2015 654,632 654,632
Creation 20,000 20,000
Release –35,000 –35,000
As at 31.12.2015 639,632 639,632
Figures in CHF thousand Provision for investment risk Total
     
As at 31.12.2015 639,632 639,632
Creation 157,000 157,000
Release –5,000 –5,000
As at 31.12.2016 791,632 791,632

14. Liabilities to pension funds

14. Liabilities to pension funds
Employer contribution reserve in TCHF Par value Waiver of usage Balance sheet Release Balance sheet Earnings from employer contribution reserve
  31.12.2015 2015 31.12.2015 2015 1.1.2015 2015 Prior year
               
Pension schemes 6,687 0 6,687 –1,896 8,374 209 68
Total 6,687 0 6,687 –1,896 8,374 209 68
Economic benefit / obligation and pension cost Funding surplus /  deficiency 1 Economic interest of organisation Change from prior year /  recognised in income statement in reporting year Contributions recognised in reporting period Pension cost in personnel costs
  31.12.2015 31.12.2015 1.1.2015     2015 Prior year
               
Pension plans with funding surplus 181,465 0 0 0 26,216 29,443 28,856
Total 181,465 0 0 0 26,216 29,443 28,856
Employer contribution reserve in TCHF Par value Waiver of usage Balance sheet Release Balance sheet Earnings from employer contribution reserve
  31.12.2016 2016 31.12.2016 2016 31.12.2016 2016 Prior year
               
Pension schemes 5,476 0 5,476 –1,378 6,687 –167 209
Total 5,476 0 5,476 –1,378 6,687 –167 209
Economic benefit / obligation and pension cost Funding surplus /  deficiency 1 Economic interest of organisation Change from prior year /  recognised in income statement in reporting year Contributions recognised in reporting period Pension cost in personnel costs
  31.12.2016 31.12.2016 31.12.2015     2016 Prior year
               
Pension plans with funding surplus 150,191 0 0 0 30,096 30,096 29,443
Total 150,191 0 0 0 30,096 30,096 29,443

1 The information is based on the audited 2015 and 2014 annual financial statements of the staff pension fund foundation of Helsana Insurance Company Ltd.

15. Supplementary information

Contingent receivables / liabilities

Within the scope of Group VAT taxation, the Helsana Group is jointly and severally liable to the Swiss Federal Tax Administration. Verein Artisana is also included in the VAT group together with the fully consolidated companies.

Significant related companies

Figures in CHF thousand Transactions with the Helsana Group (net) 1 Investments 2 Technical provisions 2
  2016 2015 31.12.2015 31.12.2014 31.12.2015 31.12.2014
             
Name            
Solida Insurance Ltd, 8048 Zurich 11,637 10,848 594,515 557,868 531,275 488,344
Helsana Legal Protection Ltd, 5000 Aarau 16,886 16,229 40,086 37,620 35,958 32,468

1 The transactions with associated companies include the sum of the statements of these companies, which include the transferred net premiums less any profit sharing and compensation for administration.

2 The figures have been taken from the 2015 Annual Report.